When Doing Your Best Isn't Enough

Leadership isn't always about making the right decision. Sometimes it's about making a decision you know will hurt someone, living with the weight of it, and recognizing that doing your best doesn't necessarily make things better for the people affected.

Josh Ether

11/6/20263 min read

There are moments in leadership that make you question whether you're cut out for it.

Not because you don't know what you're doing, but because sometimes knowing exactly what you're doing makes it that much harder.

Recently, I had a difficult conversation with someone I lead. They were disappointed with their year-end performance rating and the news that they wouldn't be receiving a promotion.

And you know what? I agreed with them.

I believed they deserved a higher rating. I believed they'd earned a promotion. I understood their frustration because, quite frankly, I shared it.

But I was in a position where I had to make difficult decisions across the people I lead. Decisions constrained by circumstances that weren't entirely within my control, but that I was still responsible for making.

That's a particularly uncomfortable place to be as a leader.

We talk a lot about advocating for our people, recognizing their contributions, and helping them grow. But what happens when you do all of those things and still can't give someone what they've earned?

What happens when the person sitting across from you is right to be disappointed?

I think that's where leadership gets real.

It's easy to talk about empathy when you can solve someone's problem. It's considerably harder when you're part of the reason they're hurting.

This person told me they felt unappreciated and undervalued.

That hurt to hear. Not because I thought they were being unfair, but because I understood why they felt that way.

And the reality is, my intentions don't change their experience.

I can explain the circumstances, describe the constraints, and reassure them that their contributions matter. But none of that changes the rating they received or the promotion they didn't get.

Sometimes explanations are necessary, but they aren't solutions.

I wouldn't blame this person if they decided to explore other opportunities, whether within the organization or somewhere else entirely. I'd be disappointed to lose them, absolutely. But I also recognize that people have careers to build, families to support, and aspirations that extend beyond my ability to advocate for them.

That's something I think we occasionally forget as leaders.

We're not just making decisions about performance ratings, compensation, or promotions. We're making decisions that affect people's lives.

And those decisions deserve more consideration than a spreadsheet, a calibration meeting, or a conversation about available opportunities can ever fully capture.

I've replayed this situation in my head more times than I'd like to admit. Questioning what I could have done differently. Wondering whether there was another option I overlooked. Thinking about whether I advocated hard enough.

Maybe that's healthy to a point. Maybe it isn't.

But I don't want to become the kind of leader who can make decisions like these without feeling the weight of them.

At the same time, I have to recognize that feeling terrible about a decision doesn't necessarily mean it was the wrong one. And feeling confident that I did my best doesn't mean the outcome was fair to everyone involved.

Both things can be true.

I listened. I acknowledged their frustration without trying to explain it away. I didn't ask them to be happy with the outcome or pretend that understanding the circumstances should make it easier to accept.

Because sometimes the most respectful thing you can do is allow someone to be disappointed without making them responsible for making you feel better about it.

I never wanted to find myself in this particular situation.

But the more I've thought about it, the more I've realized that this is precisely what I signed up for when I accepted the responsibility of leading people.

Not just the celebrations, promotions, career milestones, and moments when everything falls into place.

The uncomfortable conversations, the imperfect decisions, and the responsibility to stand behind outcomes I wish had been different.

Leadership isn't for the faint of heart. Not because leaders need to be hardened or emotionally detached, but because they need to care deeply while accepting that caring won't always be enough.

I did the best I could with the circumstances in front of me.

I still wish I'd been able to do more.

And perhaps that's the part of leadership we don't talk about enough.

Sometimes there isn't a decision that feels right. There's simply a decision you have to make, a person who has to live with it, and a responsibility to keep showing up for them afterward.

Contact me

Josh@MindsUnleashed.org

Connect With Me: